12 Must-Try Italian Restaurants in New York City in 2025

Best Italian food

Italian food is loved all over the globe. It uses fresh ingredients, has strong flavors, and can be used in many ways. From tasty pizza and pasta to special dishes from different areas, Italian food is always a treat. Eating together and enjoying how food is made makes it even better. If you’re planning a trip to New York City soon, read on to explore the best Italian restaurants the city has to offer.

New York City has many great places to eat. Today, we will explore 12 Italian restaurants that you should visit. Get ready for a tasty trip!

Top Italian Restaurants in NYC

Carbone

Carbone is an Italian-American restaurant with a classic feel. It will make you feel like you’ve gone back in time. Their spicy rigatoni vodka is very popular. You have to try it!

Rubirosa

Rubirosa is a family restaurant that is known for its thin-crust pizzas and simple Italian food. The tie-dye pizza looks great and tastes amazing.

Lucali

Lucali is a treasure in Brooklyn. They make pizza into an art. Their calzones are famous. The cozy space is great for a date.

Lilia

Lilia brings the heart of Italy to Williamsburg. Their handmade pasta and seafood cooked in a wood-fired oven are the stars of the show.

I Buco Alimentari e Vineria

At I Buco Alimentari e Vineria, you’ll feel like you’re in a rustic market. You can enjoy some of the best Italian food. Their homemade salami and fresh bread are wonderful.

Scarpetta

Scarpetta means luxury dining. Their spaghetti with tomato and basil is their main dish. They know how to make simple food taste amazing.

Aerea Morini

Aerea Morini takes you to the Amilia ran region of Italy. The food is rich and full of flavor. The tagel with Ragu Antico is so good, you’ll want more.

Frankie’s 457 Spuntino

Frankie’s 457 Spuntino has a relaxed feel and really good food. Their meatballs are a must-try. People say they are some of the best in the city.

Piccola Cucina Enoteca Siciliana

Want a taste of Sicily? Go to Piccola Cucina Enoteca Siciliana. Their seafood menu is real and full of Mediterranean flavors.

Via Carota

Via Carota captures the essence of Italian dining with its focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients and simple, yet flavorful dishes. This West Village gem offers a menu of small plates perfect for sharing, allowing diners to experience a wide range of tastes and textures.

Fiaschetteria Pistoia

Fiaschetteria Pistoia is like a cozy trip to Tuscany. The paperell al singale, a wild boar ragu, is a filling dish. It will make you feel like you’re in the hills of Tuscany.

Monte’s Trattoria

Monte’s Trattoria is a historic restaurant. It has been serving Italian classics since 1918. Their homemade pasta and live jazz music make for a great time.

Quality Italian

Lastly, Quality Italian changes how we see steakhouse food with an Italian touch. The chicken parm pizza is new and has quickly become a favorite.

Try Italian Food in New York City

Each of these restaurants offers something special. They show how diverse and rich New York City’s food scene is. So, which one will you visit first?

Facebook
X
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Telegram
Picture of Aveline Lux

Aveline Lux

Aveline Lux is a visionary writer and digital storyteller, using her blog on CitiWell Shop as a platform to explore the intersection of creativity, commerce, and culture.

Traveling extensively across continents, Aveline draws inspiration from different cultures and global trends, infusing her articles with unique perspectives and practical insights.

Aveline enjoys photography, hiking through nature trails, and curating playlists that fuel her creative process.

Discover the 10 Best Luxury 5-Star Hotels in Paris

Paris, the City of Love, is known for its beauty and charm. If you want the full Parisian experience, a luxury hotel is a must. Here are ten of the best 5-star hotels in Paris, where classic style meets modern comfort. You’re sure to find the perfect place to stay.

Read More »

Your Ultimate Guide to Sun Protection

We all know how important it is to shield our skin from the sun’s rays. Sunscreen is a key player, but it’s not the only tool in your arsenal. This guide covers other ways to protect your skin, including clothing, hats, and seeking shade. Understanding UPF Clothing UPF stands for

Read More »

10 Must-Have Designer Bags in 2025

Are you curious about the most popular designer bags for 2025? This year, some brands are making a big comeback! We’ve gathered the top 10 bags that everyone wants right now. From classic styles to new favorites, let’s jump into the list and see which bags are leading the way.

Read More »

Spanish Wine: A Beginner’s Guide

Have you ever walked down the wine aisle and felt lost looking at Spanish wines? You’re not alone! Spanish wine can seem confusing, but it’s also full of amazing values and hidden gems. Let’s explore the world of Spanish wine. You might just find your new favorite bottle! Why Choose Spanish

Read More »

Eat Like a Local: 5 Must-Try Restaurants in Paris

Paris is known for its amazing food. But finding places where Parisians actually eat can be tough. This guide will show you five restaurants loved by locals. Get ready to taste some real French flavors! Discovering Hidden Gems Forget the tourist traps. These spots offer authentic food and a true

Read More »